The town square in Nelsonville

Nelsonville timeline: Continuous legal conundrums

, , , , ,
Advertisement

NELSONVILLE, Ohio — Amid continuous ongoing legal filings, the Independent wanted to provide an illustration of the past two years of Nelsonville city councils — both of them.

Currently, Nelsonville has two city councils: one that operates the city in city hall, and another self-proclaimed council — a group consisting of people who ran for city offices in November 2025, who meet at Hocking College.

Previous timelines

View an interactive version of this image here.

Timeline by Wonderful O. Domson.

Timeline text

April–December 2024

April 22: 24CI0118 | Rita Nguyen, Sue Powell file a quo warranto in the Athens County Court of Common Pleas for their council seats. Nguyen resigned, then rescinded her resignation, in February 2024; Powell was her council appointee. Judge George McCarthy granted a temporary restraining order to restore Nguyen’s position on council as council president, and Powell’s position.

April 26: 24CA0011 | Rita Nguyen, Sue Powell file quo warranto case in the Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals.

May 3, 2024: 24CI0118 → 24CA11 | Nguyen and Powell dismiss their civil case in the local court and pursue a decision from the Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals. 

May 28, 2024: Issue 23 | Five petitioners, including Greg Smith, Barbara Bishop and Vicki McDonald, notify the city that they are pursuing via ballot initiative the abolishment of the Nelsonville City Charter — an effort that failed nine years prior.

June 28, 2024: Issue 23 | The Athens County Board of Elections verifies petitions and signatures to abolish the Nelsonville City Charter, and returns the petitions to Nelsonville City Council clerk — per charter statutes. 

July 1, 2024: 24CA0011 → 2024-0960 | Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals rejects Nguyen’s and Powell’s quo warranto claims. They then appeal to the Ohio Supreme Court.

July 18, 2024: Issue 23 + 24CI0180 | Ballot petitioners for an initiative to abolish the Nelsonville City Charter seek a mandamus in the Athens County Court of Common Pleas, asking the court to order Nelsonville to follow its charter and move forward the ballot initiative to abolish the charter. 

July 30, 2024: Issue 23 + 24CI0180 | Athens County Court of Common Pleas Judge George McCarthy orders via injunction Nelsonville to convene to consider an ordinance to allow the petitioners to pursue their ballot initiative to abolish the city charter. 

July 30, 2024: City manager | Nelsonville City Council places former City Manager Tom Cangemi on administrative leave. He started Oct. 6, 2023. 

Aug. 1, 2024: Issue 23 + 24CI0180 → 24CA0022  | Judge George McCarthy approves a requested stay of the case, pending an appeal from the Athens County Board of Elections. The appeals, 24CA0017 and 24CA0022, are consolidated.

Aug. 26, 2024: Issue 23 + 24CA0022 + 24CA0017 | The Fourth District Court of Appeals dismisses the appeal, citing lack of jurisdiction and declaring moot the injunction that ordered the Athens County Board of Elections to place Issue 23 on the ballot. 

Sept. 23, 2024: Issue 23 | Nelsonville City Council adopts an ordinance to place before voters the ballot initiative to abolish the city charter.

Sept. 25, 2024: Issue 23 | Following a court order and a Nelsonville City Council ordinance, Nelsonville City Charter, the Athens County Board of Elections approves Issue 23 to go before voters.

Oct. 31, 2024: Issue 23 + 24CA28 + 24CA29 | The Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals largely upholds Judge McCarthy’s prior decision ordering Nelsonville to place the ballot initiative abolishing the city charter before voters.

Nov. 6, 2024: Issue 23 | Nelsonville passes Issue 23, to abolish the city charter effective Jan. 1, 2026.

January–June 2025

Feb. 20, 2025: 2024-0960 → | The Ohio Supreme Court reverses and remands Sue Powell and Rita Nguyen’s quo warranto case. 

March 24, 2025: City manager | Cangemi resigns, effective April 7, 2024. 

April 14, 2025: → 2025CRB00504 | Nelsonville Police Department arrests Nguyen for allegedly disrupting a public meeting. 

May 1, 2025: City manager | Fred Holmes starts as city manager.

May 6, 2025: 25CI0136 | City of Nelsonville and City Auditor Taylor Sappington filed a legal action against Smith, claiming that he had fraudulently entered into a settlement agreement with the City of Nelsonville to resolve his many previous lawsuits against the city. 

May 6, 2025: Issue 4 | Nelsonville votes down Issue 4, a measure that would have amended the city charter to adopt a new form of government, rather than abolish the charter entirely.

June–December 2025

May 29, 2025: Issue 23 | The League of Women Voters of Athens County begins a series of town halls to create Nelsonville ward maps, as part of the government transition based upon Issue 23 and a statutory government beginning Jan. 1, 2026. 

July 18, 2025: 25CI0136 | Smith filed a 79-page answer to Nelsonville’s complaint, plus a counter lawsuit against Nelsonville, claiming the city had violated Smith’s terms of the agreement — plus violated his civil rights under federal law. He also claims a breach of his freedom of speech. 

July 24, 2025: 2025CRB00504 | An Athens Municipal Court jury acquits Nguyen on her disturbing a lawful meeting charge.

Aug. 11, 2025: Ordinance 54-25 | Nelsonville City Council repeals Issue 23 via Ordinance 54-25, “due to its lack of transitional plan and authority.” 

Aug. 13, 2025: 2025-1061 | Nelsonville files suit in the Ohio Supreme Court to remove statutory-based government office races from the general election ballot, arguing that because it repealed Issue 23 via Ordinance 54-25, the election is moot.

Aug. 19, 2025: 2025-1061 | The Ohio Supreme Court dismisses the City of Nelsonville’s complaint saying that the city missed a deadline to file a brief and present evidence to the court. 

Aug, 27, 2025: 2025-1061 | The Ohio Supreme Court reopens Nelsonville’s case. 

Aug. 29, 2025: Elections protest | The City of Nelsonville files a protest at the Athens County Board of Elections against write-in mayoral candidates, Fred Holmes and Nancy Sonick.

Sept. 4, 2025: Elections protest | The Athens County Board of Elections denies a protest filed against write-in candidates who have been certified to run for office this November.

Sept. 17, 2025: 2025-1061 | The Ohio Supreme Court denies the city of Nelsonville’s request to remove the certified candidates who are running for city office from the upcoming general election ballot.

Sept. 19, 2025: 2025-1061 | The City of Nelsonville filed a motion for reconsideration with the Ohio Supreme Court.

Sept. 24, 2025: 2025-1061 | The Ohio Supreme Court denies 2025-1061 again. 

Sept. 29, 2025: 25CI0312 | Hashman files in the Athens County Common Pleas Court, asking the court to rule Ordinance 54-25 unconstitutional.

Oct. 6, 2025: Storm water referendum | Vicki McDonald files a referendum petition in the Athens County Board of Elections for Nelsonville City Council Ordinance 51-25, for the “approval or rejection of ordinace [sic] establishing a storm sewer fee for all water and sewer customers and creating a storm sewer line item.”

Oct. 8, 2025: Storm water referendum | Per procedures set out in the Nelsonville City Charter, the board of elections provides petition certification results to the Nelsonville City Clerk of Council for the proposed storm sewer referendum. 

Oct. 23, 2025: 25CI0312 | Lang denies the motion for the preliminary injunction. 

Nov. 4, 2025: Issue 23 | Nelsonville elects mayor, council president, city auditor and council members to Issue 23-based offices, whose terms begin Jan. 1, 2026; as well as individuals to one-month council terms, Dec. 1–31, 2025. 

Dec. 8, 2025: 25CI0386 | Twenty-five people filed to “Strike the Statutory Govt. Candidates Slated For Office In the City of Nelsonville, Ohio, Effective January 1, 2026.” 

Dec. 10, 2025: 25CI0312 | Judge Lang, in a five-page decision, found Hashman did not have the proper standing to bring her lawsuit and that she received no injury that would allow her to bring the action.

Dec. 19, 2025: 25CI0386 | Athens County Court of Common Pleas Judge Patrick Lang dismisses the 25-plaintiff case, introducing his decision by stating: “Simply put, the document is so defective on its face that, for the reasons explained below, it requires dismissal.”

Dec. 31, 2025: The Nelsonville City treasurer’s and auditor’s offices are vacated. 

2026: January–present

Jan. 5: Lynn Bishop, Wesley Henderson, Glenn Smith, Sue Powell, Jessica Hollenbaugh and Dan Sherman meet at Hocking College as a Nelsonville City Council. In the November 2025 general election, they all ran for Issue 23-based city offices. 

Jan. 12: City manager | Nelsonville City Council, operating under the charter, meets at city hall for its first regular meeting of the year. It held an organizational meeting Jan. 6. The council passes an ordinance Jan. 12 to hire new interim city manager Danette Miller. 

Jan. 21: 26CI0017 | Andrea Nicole Thompson Hashman, who ran unopposed for city auditor in the 2025 general election, files a civil suit in the Athens County Court of Common Pleas, seeking declaratory judgment against Nelsonville. 

Feb. 5: 26CA0003 | Statutory council members file an appeal in the Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals and seek a petition for quo warranto. 

Feb. 23: 26CI0017 | Thompson Hashman voluntarily dismisses her case that she filed in January.

March 2: 25CI0386 → 26CA0008 | Thompson Hashman appeals Lang’s Feb. 2 decision that denied her motion for violation of Ohio Revised Code, frivolous conduct in filing civil claims. 

April 1: 24CA0011 | After nearly two years, the Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals issues a decision on Rita Nguyen and Sue Powell’s quo warranto case, essentially ruling their claims moot.

April 13: 24CA0011 → 2026-0429 | Rita Nguyen and Sue Powell appeal to the Ohio Supreme Court the latest district court’s opinion.

April 23: 25CI0136 | Judge issues stay on case, “until the City of Nelsonville’s form of government is validated by a court of competent jurisdiction.”

June 10: 26CA0003 | Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals declines to rule on quo warranto case for those elected via Issue 23; cites issues with the indeterminate legality of Ordinance 54-25.

July 23: Storm water referendum | Greg Smith, acting as clerk of the statutory Nelsonville City Council while citing procedures set out in the Nelsonville City Charter, submits a clerk’s certification to the board of elections for the proposed storm water referendum. 

July 27: 26CA0003 → 2026-0947 | Statutory council members appeal the latest decision to the Ohio Supreme Court. 

Aug. 12: Storm water referendum | The Athens County Board of Elections votes 3-1 to reject the proposed Nelsonville storm water referendum. The Athens County Prosecutor’s Office advised the board because the initiative addresses appropriations, it cannot be voted upon under Nelsonville City Charter statutes, nor Ohio Revised Code. 

Aug. 27: 26CA0022 | Andrea Nicole Thompson Hashman files suit in the Ohio Fourth District Court of Appeals, asking the court to allow her to fill the city auditor’s office. Thompson Hashman ran unopposed for the office, based upon Issue 23’s passage, in November 2025. 

Sept 29: Recall | Nelsonville City Council Clerk Erica Padgett submits the recall petitions she received to Athens County Board of Elections to recall Amy Hollenbaugh, Charlotte Beach, Cameron Peck, Gregg Clement, McCray Powell, Nic Joseph-Saul and Nancy Sonick. 

Oct. 1: 2026-0429 | The Ohio Supreme Court again reverses and remands the appellate court’s latest opinion on Nguyen and Powell’s quo warranto claims. The supreme court found that the appellate court could not rule Nguyen’s claims moot without first deciding upon which government should prevail in Nelsonville; nor did it rule on the issue of her rescinded resignation.

Oct. 1: Recall | Athens County Board of Elections returns petition verification results to the Nelsonville City Council clerk. 

Oct. 2: Recall | Former Nelsonville City Council Clerk Danielle Huber verifies that recall petition signatures meet threshold requirements set by the city charter.

Oct. 14: Recall | Nelsonville City Council passes a resolution finding the recall petition sufficient and sets the special election date for Tuesday, Dec. 15.

Oct. 19: Recall | Athens County Board of Elections receives ballot resolution language for recall election. 

Oct. 21: Recall | Athens County Board of Elections sets recall election for May 4, 2027, primary election.

Nov. 2: Council membership | Council member Nancy Sonick resigns after a special meeting.

Nov. 9: Council membership | The council removes Cameron Peck from his president position and he resigns immediately after.

May 4, 2027:  Recall | 2027 primary election.

Keri Johnson is a journalist and poet from Southeast Ohio. Before co-founding the Independent, Keri served as an AmeriCorps VISTA at Rural Action and worked as a general assignment reporter for The Logan Daily News. Keri is a first-generation graduate of Ohio University’s E.W. Scripps School of Journalism, grateful to work in Appalachian Ohio and passionate about capturing its stories.