ATHENS, Ohio — Concerns about a $120,000 annual consulting services contract between the City of Athens and a local firm were raised again during Athens City Council’s meeting on Monday.
At council’s Nov. 9 meeting, Michael Wood, 3rd Ward, cited concerns over Sunday Creek Horizons’ political giving and its role in turmoil at the Outdoor Recreation Council of Appalachia, the council of governments that has overseen the development of the Baileys Trail System.
On Monday night, Wood said he had received communications from former council members Jeffrey Reisner and Solveig Spjedlness, who both vacated their seats in 2025.
Wood shared a text from Risner stating that he agreed with Wood about his statements concerning Sunday Creek Horizons’ political donations.
“I had been under the impression that [Sunday Creek Horizons] was a consulting and management organization not a political lobbying company,” Reisner wrote. “The idea that part of the fees the city was charged for services went to political campaigns and candidates makes me very angry. Such actions should have been made clear in any contract as part of services contracted.”
“All in all I am very disappointed in [Sunday Creek Horizons] and the city government should find alternatives,” Reisner wrote.
In a Nov. 13 email to the council, Spjeldnes urged the council to cancel the forthcoming 2027 Sunday Creek Horizons contract.
“I realize that they have been helpful in the past,” she wrote. “We realize that, but they are done in my opinion. The organization is so tied to the former Ohio Republican government that they likely will not be able to advocate effectively on our behalf.”
Wood said he had also received a communication from a local business that cut off contract negotiations with Sunday Creek Horizons over the political leanings of the company comprising Sunday Creek Horizons’ “conservative stakeholders.”
Earlier this month, the Athens County Independent published an analysis of political donations by Sunday Creek Horizons and its principals since the 2024 general election. The analysis found that the firm gave about three times as much to Republican candidates than was given to Democrats.
In an email to the Independent sent Tuesday, Spjeldnes also questioned the need for consultants at all:
There are other firms the city can consider for these purposes, but a broader question is why is it now standard practice for cities and organizations to hire such firms to advocate for them? They are ‘middle men’ who siphon off monies for needed social purposes in part through their fees and in part because (they) turn around and give some of these fees to the campaign coffers of our elected officials. The system is all quite slimy.
Mayor Steve Patterson pushed back against Wood’s criticisms of the firm. The city does not need to seek competitive bids for the consulting contract, he said, because the Ohio Revised Code exempts consultants from competitive bidding requirements.
Patterson said that the city has received $19 for every $1 paid to Sunday Creek Horizons. The firm’s work secured state funding for the Athens Armory project, the Athens Farmers Market Community Pavilion, and the Appalachian Community Grant Program to fund underground placement of utility lines, Patterson said.
“One of the things I hope everyone recognizes is the challenge of seeking state funding when you have a state legislature that is a majority one party and the city of Athens is a majority the other party,” Patterson said.
Council President Micah McCarey said that members of the city’s Commission on Disabilities want the city to “identify a clear path forward” for completion of an Americans with Disabilities Act transition plan that Sunday Creek Horizons has been working on since last year.
In a statement shared with the Independent Nov. 10, Sunday Creek Horizons President Zack Space denied that the firm was involved in political maneuvering that nearly cost ORCA $750,000 in previously approved state funding earlier this year.
Elected officials salaries
Following a suggestion from Alan Swank, 4th Ward, The Committee of the Whole expressed a consensus that officials’ salary increases be tied to the annual adjustment of the federal government’s Consumer Price Index each October.
Since 2014, salaries for the mayor, auditor, law director, treasurer, council president and council members have increased about 2% annually. However, a report by McCarey found that bringing elected officials’ pay level with inflation would require an adjustment of 7.1% in 2028.
Auditor Josh Thomas said the city would need to rely on the CPI to populate its salary spreadsheets within the forthcoming annual budget.
Council members agreed that it should determine minimum and maximum increases. The maximum would likely be increases of 5% or 6%, and the minimum would likely mean no increase, or 0%.
Salaries for elected officials were moved forward for an upcoming first ordinance reading.
Special event street closures returned to committee
Two proposals regarding special event street closures and a fees table for organizations were returned to the Transportation Committee for revision, following lengthy discussion Monday. Ordinances 95-26 and 96-26 were set for second and third readings, respectively.
The committee, chaired by Clodfelter, might first form an Ad Hoc Street Closure subcommittee. That subcommittee would include Clodfelter, Assistant-Safety Director Andrew Chiki, and neighborhood association members, event organizers and other stakeholders.
Brandon Thompson, who has organized events such as Ohio Brew Week and Athens Halloween, said it is important that “everyone’s voice is heard,” not just from event promoters and supporters but those concerned with events “love them or hate them.”
Athens resident Rob Delach, president of the Porchfest board, said he has interacted with Chiki with a good written dialogue but still with unresolved questions.
Kristie Thomas, of Avon Place, spoke as an individual and said she appreciates the city lowering the neighborhood gathering fee of one block from $300 to $150. The association plans about four events per year with all volunteers, she said, and their personal funding is limited.

Thomas said she hopes the city will consider any “roadblocks,” such as the required surcharge of $200 for a vendor or food truck. That amount will be on top of paying the vendor $250–$300, she said, which means any one event can become costly depending on how much is offered to those attending. She also would like clarification on several issues, including refund policies if an event were to be canceled.
Other business
Three agenda items were added during the meeting:
- Ordinance 120-26, the Welcome Home Ohio Program project on Hudson Street, received first reading after Swank said the language was received Monday. The ordinance would approve the final plan of the eight units of affordable housing, made possible through a $2 million grant. The homes, priced at $180,000 each, were made possible through a former city storage yard property offered to the project, as well as a portion of American Red Cross property. Swank said additional tasks such as a survey are to take place, but the project should break ground next year.
- Ordinance 121-26 amends city code section 17.01.051 related to municipal income tax collection by requiring all employers with 10 or more employees to submit tax collection information through acceptable electronic delivery systems.
- The council adopted Ordinance 122-26 after rules suspension and a unanimous vote, as it updates Ordinance 59-26 with the most current plan for a federal Local-Let Project for SR 682, between U.S. 33 and the Richland roundabout, a section of about three-quarters of one mile. Clodfelter, who chairs the Transportation Committee, said the newest plan for the approximately $7 million project — of which the federal share is over 90% — involves replacing cement that is 54 years old; it had a life expectancy of 50 years. The concrete includes the cloverleafs that connect SR 682 with U.S. 33, Patterson said. The city’s share of funding is just under $500,000, with the project set to begin in 2027 some time after the midway point of the year, according to Clodfelter. Traffic will be maintained in each direction during the project.
Athens City Council’s next meeting will be held 7 p.m. Monday, Nov. 23, at Athens City Hall, Council Chambers, third floor, 8 E. Washington St. Meetings are also streamed online.
Regular sessions are on the first and third Mondays of the month; committee meetings are on the second and fourth Mondays.

