Inside Courts Nelsonville City Hall

Catching up on Athens County litigation

, ,
Advertisement

In Inside Courts, retired judge Tom Hodson explains the complexities of the law and legal cases, helping you understand what’s at stake — and how it affects you. 

It’s time to catch up and update you on several court fronts. 

As you might have discerned, litigation of all types moves in fits and starts — a jerky trajectory that doesn’t follow a precise timetable. That’s what is happening with major cases we have been tracking.

So, it’s time to look at several of these cases and bring you up to speed.

Nelsonville’s Ohio Supreme Court case

This is the case filed by the statutory group of officials asking the Ohio Supreme Court to nullify Ordinance 54-25, which negated the 2024 public referendum revoking the Nelsonville City Charter.

The statutory folks are asking the court to declare them the rightful parties to run Nelsonville.

When we last examined this case, the statutory officials’ attorney Garry Hunter had filed a brief (written legal arguments) and asked for oral arguments to take place before the entire seven-member high court. Nelsonville and the current charter government had filed their answer brief through attorney Jonathan Robe.

As mentioned in that column, the statutory group had the right to file a reply brief trying to negate the arguments of the charter officials.

That reply brief was filed with the Ohio Supreme Court on Nov. 10. It advanced counter legal arguments to Nelsonville’s answer brief and reiterated many of the statutory officials’ original legal points.

Hunter argues that once the citizens’ vote revoking the charter was certified by the Athens County Board of Elections, the charter was then nullified and the charter officials had no power to pass an ordinance negating the vote of the public.

With the most recent filing by the statutory group, all written legal arguments are now before the Ohio Supreme Court.

Additionally, Hunter withdrew the original request for an oral argument before the justices. The charter group had not asked for argument, so Hunter asked the court not to delay a decision any longer. 

Even though both parties have not requested oral arguments, the justices could require one and schedule one. If there are no oral arguments, then the case is ready for a Supreme Court decision. 

Now, we wait. There is no way of predicting how long it will be before the court renders a final decision on this chaos.

Nelsonville’s Fourth District Court of Appeals case

On Oct. 1, the Ohio Supreme Court sent a case involving former city official Rita Nguyen back to the court of appeals for that court to decide which government should prevail: statutory or charter.

The appellate court had refused to make that decision earlier. 

The fact that the Ohio Supreme Court sent that case back to the court of appeals might be a preview of things to come on the case now before that court. It might foreshadow the Ohio Supreme Court also sending the statutory council’s case back to the court of appeals for a decision.

If that happens, there will be further delays of an unknown period.

The court of appeals does not have any of their records online, so it is impossible to see the exact status of the current Nguyen case without doing a public records request, but I doubt a decision will be forthcoming any time soon.

One of the judges who had heard the original case, Judge Peter Abele, died recently and a new judge was just elected to fill his term. The court is expected to give that new judge some time to get acclimated before jumping into such a thorny case.

So, I don’t think we will get a decision on that matter any time soon. That leaves both of these cases in limbo. 

Meanwhile, there will be a recall election for the charter officers next spring and the charter council president and another charter council person recently resigned amidst controversy.

In short, chaos continues to reign in Nelsonville.

Effort to remove Judge George McCarthy

In this matter, we also are in judicial limbo.

As previously reported, Athens County Prosecuting Attorney Keller J. Blackburn filed a six-page affidavit with the Ohio Supreme Court on Oct. 1 seeking to disqualify Athens County Common Pleas Judge George McCarthy from presiding over the case of Mark Anthony Butcher.

Blackburn claimed Judge McCarthy has shown bias and prejudice against the prosecutor’s office. 

The Ohio Supreme Court, through Justice Sharon Kennedy requested that Judge McCarthy file his response, within 21 days of Oct. 1. 

Judge McCarthy filed his response on Oct. 19, claiming that Blackburn was trying to punish the court for disagreeing with the prosecution. McCarthy characterized Blackburn’s request for disqualification as badgering the court for opposing positions taken by the prosecutor.

The matter is now in the hands of Justice Kennedy, and there is no timeline for her decision. So, we wait.

I checked with the Ohio Supreme Court’s Public Information Office this week and was told that there has been no decision yet and they did not know when a decision would be forthcoming.

Former football coach Brian Smith v. Ohio University

After being terminated in December 2025 from his position as head football coach, Brian Smith filed a lawsuit against Ohio University in the Ohio Court of Claims for wrongful termination and damages.

The suit was filed on May 8. On June 22, OU filed its answer to the lawsuit, denying wrongdoing. 

Once the complaint and answer were filed, Judge Lisa L. Sadler held a telephonic “case management conference” on July 23. A case management conference is standard in these types of cases to set out dates and deadlines to be met by the parties.

On July 29, the claims court set a trial date for this case to be Dec. 6–10, 2027 — over a year away. That trial would decide whether there is liability on the part of Ohio University and if so, how much in damages should be paid to Smith.

I know. That seems like a long way away, but much needs to be done prior to a trial.

The next pretrial conference between the court and the parties is scheduled for Oct. 21, 2027.

Meanwhile, the claims court set deadlines for the parties to exchange names of expert witnesses and a deadline of June 2, 2027, to complete all discovery in the case. 

Discovery is when the parties exchange information and documents, answer written questions under oath and sit for depositions (oral testimony under oath prior to trial).

The claims court also set a deadline for any pretrial motions to be made by July 16, 2027.

It should be emphasized that this case can be settled between the parties at any time prior to trial if they can reach an agreement on liability and an amount of damages, if any, to be paid.

It is estimated by most credible court watchers that about 95% of all civil cases like this one are settled between the parties prior to trial. We will wait and see on this one.

Caitlin Mohler v. Ohio University

This is a case that we have not yet examined in depth. We will be doing that in later columns.

Essentially, this is a complaint filed in federal court by an Ohio University employee who claims that the university was derelict in pursuing her multiple complaints of sexual harassment by her employer, former WOUB General Manager Mark Brewer.

The case was filed in October and has been assigned to Chief Judge Sarah D. Morrison and Magistrate Judge Kimberly A. Jolson

On Oct. 21, Magistrate Jolson filed a Scheduling Order for the case outlining certain deadlines to be met for the parties for things like completing discovery (July 20, 2027) and filing dispositive motions (motions to resolve the case prior to trial: Sept. 24, 2027)

Most importantly, the court is urging the parties to try to settle this case before trial.

Mohler, through her attorney, must make a settlement demand by Dec. 11 and Ohio University must respond by no later than Jan. 11, 2027. The parties must also attend a mandatory Attorney Mediator Conference in April 2027 if settlement has not been reached by then.

In both this case and the Brian Smith case, Ohio University is paying outside legal counsel to represent the university.

Conclusion

Currently, we are actively following five cases and trying to translate for you what is happening in them. Two are before the Ohio Supreme Court, one is at the intermediate level court of appeals (Fourth District Court of Appeals), one is in the Ohio Court of Claims, and one is in federal court in Columbus.

Two involve the City of Nelsonville and two involve Ohio University as defendants.

All are at various stages but there is one thing that they all have in common. They have not been resolved, and we are waiting for the slow grind of the legal processes to work.

While the judicial system slogs forward, we wait and we watch.

We will keep you informed whenever there is a break in the legal logjam.

Hodson has had dual career paths throughout his professional career in law and journalism. He was a trial attorney for over 20 years and was a trial judge in both Municipal Court and Common Pleas Court in Ohio for seven years.

Hodson also served as a Judicial Fellow at the Supreme Court of the United States in the Administrative Office of the Chief Justice. He also has been a visiting judge on assignment by the Supreme Court of Ohio.

Throughout his legal career, Hodson pursued journalistic projects both in print and broadcast.

Hodson also has been active in producing public affairs programming for radio and is the host of WOUB’s weekly public affairs podcast, Spectrum. He is the executive producer of six other podcasts.

He has published and continues to write numerous articles and columns for newspapers, magazines, and trade journals.

He co-authored a book called Journalists’ Handbook to Ohio Courts.

He has written and been talent for numerous public television documentaries and public affairs programs.